So what is the #1 thing that's important to you?

Gameplay to me is the only thing that matters. If the story is bad I'll skip the dialog, if the graphics are bad I'll put it on a CRT, if there's no multiplayer I'll play it by myself, if there's no Achievements that's fine I play SNES games daily. The ONLY thing that matters is how the actual game feels/plays. If it's not fun to play the game I do not care how good anything else is, it won't trump the one thing games are made to do imo and that's to be played lol